Filtration, Crystallisation, Distillation or Extraction?
Choose a separation method from the property that differs: insolubility, crystallization behavior, volatility or distribution between phases.
Can a filter remove dissolved salt from water?
Ordinary filtration separates insoluble solid particles from fluid. It does not automatically retain dissolved ions. Filtering sand mixed with salt water can remove sand, but does not directly yield pure water. Match the method to an actual property difference.
| Method | Main basis | Common mistake |
|---|---|---|
| Filtration | Insoluble particles versus fluid | Treating dissolved solute as residue |
| Crystallization | Conditions for crystal formation and solubility | Assuming mother liquor has no solute left |
| Distillation | Volatility differences | Assuming one pass always produces a pure substance |
| Liquid–liquid extraction | Distribution between two immiscible liquid phases | Assuming complete transfer in one extraction |
The target changes the choice
For a paper model containing only insoluble sand, water and dissolved salt, filtration addresses sand removal. Recovering salt suggests an appropriate crystallization process. Collecting water calls for considering distillation, not treating evaporated but uncollected water as recovered product. Stability, purity requirements and equipment also matter; this is not an operating procedure.
Extraction requires suitable phases and distribution behavior. An organic layer is not always uppermost: density determines position. Preferential solubility does not mean all solute transfers. Distillation performance depends on phase behavior, not a universal boiling-point-gap shortcut.
Complete the sentence: “Because the target differs in ___, consider ___.” If you cannot name the property, do not choose by method name alone.
For layer position, compare the densities of the two solution phases rather than assuming that every organic layer is uppermost.