Chemical bonds vs intermolecular forces: what changes on melting or boiling?
Boiling water normally does not split H₂O molecules. Distinguish intramolecular bonds from intermolecular attractions first.
Is steam still H₂O?
During ordinary boiling of water, H₂O molecules retain their intramolecular O—H covalent bonds. The main changes concern intermolecular interactions, arrangement and separation. Vaporization is not the chemical decomposition of water.
| Level | In this example | During ordinary boiling |
|---|---|---|
| Within a molecule | O—H covalent bonds | Normally remain intact |
| Between molecules | Hydrogen bonding and other attractions | Interactions and separation change |
A hydrogen bond is not simply any covalent bond involving hydrogen. Its formation depends on suitable bonding to a strongly electronegative atom and an appropriate neighboring acceptor, rather than the mere presence of H.
Control the comparison before predicting boiling points
Stronger intermolecular attractions generally require more energy to separate molecules, but molecular size, shape and external pressure also matter. “Any hydrogen-bonding substance boils above every non-hydrogen-bonding substance” is not a valid universal rule. Nonpolar molecules still experience London dispersion attractions.
Ionic crystals and covalent network solids require different structural models. A NaCl crystal is discussed as an ionic lattice, not as ordinary packing of independent NaCl molecules. Identify the type of structure before applying a molecular explanation.
A conceptual check
“Boiling water requires energy, so every water molecule splits into H and O.” The first part is true; the conclusion does not follow. Supplying energy does not automatically establish a chemical reaction. A useful explanation identifies which structural level changes under the specified conditions.